Internal Recruiter vs Agency: When You Shouldn’t Hire a Recruitment Firm
Every growing company eventually faces the same question. Should you use a recruitment firm or hire your own recruiter? The internal recruiter vs agency decision comes down to cost, volume and the type of roles you’re filling.
Maz Artang, Executive Headhunter and founder of Aughdem Recruitment, offers a refreshingly honest answer. “If you’re hiring all the time, I’m probably not your best option,” he says.
What an External Recruiter Costs
An external recruiter typically costs $15,000 to $25,000 for each hire. For senior and executive roles, that fee covers significant work. It includes market mapping, direct outreach to passive candidates, assessment and a firm that owns the search from start to finish.
For companies that hire occasionally, this model is efficient. You pay for expertise only when you need it.
What an Internal Recruiter Costs
On the other hand, a solid internal recruiter costs around $100,000 a year. That figure reflects salary, benefits and the tools they need to do the job.
An internal recruiter works only for you. As a result, they build deep knowledge of your culture, your teams and your hiring needs. However, that value only pays off if they have enough roles to fill.
The 6 Hire Rule for Internal Recruiter vs Agency
So how do you decide? Maz uses a simple rule of thumb based on senior leadership hiring volume.
- Fewer than 6 senior leadership hires a year: use a recruitment firm, because it’s cheaper
- Consistently more than 6 senior hires a year: hire your own recruiter
- Somewhere in between: get expert advice on your specific situation
The logic is straightforward. At 6 senior hires a year, agency fees start to approach the cost of a full-time internal recruiter. Beyond that point, an in-house hire usually makes more financial sense.
Other Factors to Consider
Cost isn’t the only factor in the internal recruiter vs agency decision. You should also think about:
- Seniority: executive and C-suite roles often need the reach and confidentiality of a search firm
- Specialization: niche roles may require a recruiter with deep industry networks
- Confidentiality: replacing a current leader usually calls for an external partner
- Speed: firms with established networks can often move faster on urgent roles
- Workload: an internal recruiter can only manage so many searches at once
In many cases, companies use both. For example, an internal recruiter may handle volume hiring, while a search firm handles executive roles.
When a Search Firm Makes the Most Sense
Executive searches are a different kind of work. The best candidates are usually passive, and reaching them takes a strong network and careful positioning. In addition, many executive searches are confidential.
For that reason, even companies with internal recruiters often bring in an executive search firm for senior leadership roles.
Not Sure Which Option Is Right?
If you’re somewhere in the middle, you’re not alone. Many growing companies sit right on the line between these two models.
“If you’re not sure what makes sense, reach out,” Maz says. “I’ll tell you what I’d do.”
Contact Aughdem Recruitment for an honest assessment of your hiring plan. And if you do decide to use a firm, make sure you work with just one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it cheaper to hire an internal recruiter or use an agency?
If you make fewer than 6 senior hires a year, a recruitment firm is usually cheaper. If you consistently make more than 6, an internal recruiter at around $100,000 a year often costs less.
How much does an external recruiter cost per hire?
Typically $15,000 to $25,000 per hire, depending on the role and its seniority.